What is every AFC East Division team's record against the point spread as an underdog since the 2009 season?

Definitions
Team ATS Record Cover % MOV ATS +/-
New England 28-26-2 51.9% -1.2 +3.0
Miami 74-72-3 50.7% -6.1 -0.4
Buffalo 59-60-7 49.6% -5.4 +0.1
NY Jets 71-85-7 45.5% -7.3 -0.8